We stayed at Suncrest Villas last January and are returning the first week of 2008. The decor is cute and islandy. The villas are stocked with lots of towels and every kitchen utensil possible. The beach is just steps away as is the marina and restaurants. A great relaxing vacation.

The villas are cute, but they weren't sealed well and had mice. The owner refused to give us any part of our money back when we wanted to stay somewhere else. We had to deal with trapping and poisoning the mice ourselves, as there are no phones to call for help, and the owner isn't based in the Bahamas. It ruined our vacation. I recommend Island Dreams Properties instead. They are great!
Treasure Cay is beautiful. I recommend it to anyone who loves beautiful beaches, great food, and warm people. Just don't stay at Suncrest.