Gershwin Hotel

  • Add to Trip Check Rates
  • 7 East 27th Street.
    New York, New York 10016
    212-545-8000Website
  • Not quite right? Change PhotoUpdate Address
Ishtar
Ishtar
First Reviewer
2 out of 5
Avg. Member Rating
5
Reviews
4
Photos

Good gone Bad, very bad!

  • May 29, 2008
  • Rated 1 of 5 by a traveler from Travelocity.com
We used to stay in this hotel couple years ago and we like it. The hotel isn't 5 stars hotel but it used to be a hip place for young at heart traveler whom want something new and more excitement rather than chain or hi-rise hotels. We wet back there to celebrate our anniversary and expect the same service or more with a room rate that similar to 5 stars hotel. What we found was a run down on everything from sevice to the room itself.The front desk look like a zoo just like what you found at 1 or 2 stars hotel, the room were old and very dirty, we end up stay outside untill late at night because we didn't want to go back to our hotel. Beside, we didn't sleep at all the first night because of the noise that came from the bar across the street that open until 4 am. and we were on the 12th floor!! One last thing, if you are going to pay $260 per night for a hotel, you would expect the hotel to provide shampoo for you at lease, right?....wrong! ,not this hotel.

Served its purpose

  • May 22, 2008
  • Rated 3 of 5 by a traveler from Travelocity.com
The Gershwin hotel is not as nice as their description lets on, but it was fine for what we needed it and it served its purpose to us. The bed was extremely uncomfortable. It bowed in the middle and my husband and I were continuously rolling toward the center. It really needed a new mattress. The room size was fine and we had plenty of space for my son's pack n play. The bathroom was adequate, but the toilet ran constantly so we had to be sure to keep the door shut. The window in the bathroom also didn't close all the way, so it got REALLY cold in there overnight. It was clean and we felt secure. The hotel is centrally located, 2 blocks from the subway, 3 blocks from a parking garage (where the Gershwin got us an excellent rate!), within walking distance to the Empire State Building, Harold square, Madison Square park, and many other Tourist destinations. We enjoyed our stay, but will not likely stay there again as we would prefer to try a different location within Manhattan if we return. If you are looking for a place to lay your head at night and to wash your face in the morning that is centrally located and clean, the Gershwin is a good choice. If you're looking for luxury and lots of amenities, it is not the right place for you!

I'll Take Manhattan ...and The Gershwin!

  • November 21, 2007
  • Rated 4 of 5 by a traveler from Travelocity.com
A really hip, fun, funky hotel downtown that is perfect for the "not your typical tourist kind of place". The staff is clean cut and multi lingual with a real sense of fun. Nearby the Museum and great shopping with fantastic diners and shops nearby. If you want to get a taste of real NYC and agreat bargain taboot, this is it. I loved it more than "CATS" I want to see it again and again!

The Gershwin Hotel

  • January 23, 2006
  • Rated 2 of 5 by ParadiseOTR from Melbourne, Australia
The Gershwin Hotel would have to be considered on the higher-end of the 'budget accommodation' scale for New York. There are cheaper hostels around, but they don't look as pretty. The facade of the building is stunning with the property's art collection adorning even the outside walls. The vibe continues inside with a great pop art collection together with prints and photos from a range of artists and inspirations.

Unfortunately, looks weren't enough to make this place too easy to recommend. It is probably too expensive ($70 AUD) for a very crowded dorm with minimal amenities on site. The internet on offer is expensive and unreliable and there are no kitchen facilities available, forcing you to buy all meals and giving the budget a further kicking.

The staff, however, are extremely helpful. The 24-hour reception desk is always attended by professional looking and helpful folks who will answer inumerable questions and are happy to track down information when they don't know the answer.

The Gershwin also has location going for it. In a big way. A block from the lower end of Fifth Avenue for shopping, and a walk up Broadway takes you past Macy's for shopping and you'll find yourself in Times Square before you know it. Head south and you have Union Square and the Flatiron Building or a short Subway trip to Lower Manhattan or the Village.

All in all, if you are looking for budget-friendly hostel accommodation, you should probably look further than the Gershwin. Unless the art collection really wins you, the extra dollars don't translate into a better hostel experience than others on offer - others that are also conveniently located, just to other things in a city full of sights to see.

From journal A First Taste of the Big Apple

Editor Pick

The Gershwin Hotel

  • July 24, 2003
  • Rated 2 of 5 by Ishtar from Bayside, New York
The Gershwin Hotel

How would you like to sleep in a room where a larger than life Picasso is staring at you unflinchingly? Well, this was my room on the 12th floor of this renovated, très hip and chic hotel. The Gershwin Hotel had been booked for a group of us, and I understand the above rate ($129/night) was a corporate discount.

At first, the appearance of the hotel can be a bit unsettling, especially if you are arriving around midnight, and fatigue has gotten the best of you. As we pull up in front, I see gigantic, hornlike protrusions from the wall, which are lit, and are quite suggestive of perhaps a "bordello"? It could be the influence of the Museum of Sex which is right next door. Once in the lobby, I feel much better. It's quite colorful, lots of art, aluminum doors cover the original 100 year old elevators. The reception area is to the right of the registration desk, and there, you can relax on retro couches, or listen to music if you're early enough. There are live performances nightly, and unfortunately, by the time I arrive at the hotel after each show day, I can only think of one thing: my bed.

I do get help with my luggage as I have been travelling now for more than a week, and have yet another week to go. Each floor has separate art installations that feature international painters, photographers, mostly avant-garde. The floors are painted in bright colors, as in red. The room is simple with basic amenities like a telephone, cable TV, a hair dryer in the bathroom, an old fashioned armoire for clothes! And I know all about those extra tall curtains covering those extra tall New York windows! It means that if you open them, you'll be facing a brick wall . . .

Under Picasso, there are two armchairs and a small table which becomes the suitcase station. There is a desk, but I wonder what one can do there . . . no internet access from the room; ah, it's beginning to feel like Europe. You can access your email in a remote part of the lobby where it's about $1 for 5 minutes. Sometimes, the machine is temperamental and refuses your credit card, so you have to feed it dollars, and early in the morning, it takes a great deal of pleasure throwing them up back at you.

There was an in-site café, but during my stay, it was undergoing renovation which was actually great, as I got acquainted again with the typical NY coffee shop experience every morning.

The hotel has location going for it if you are wanting to stay around midtown, or heading for Soho. For the Jacob Javits Center, I would not pick this venue, as it is way too far. And oh, stay away from the limousine service kiosk in the lobby. You can do much better on your own with the yellow pages.

From journal New York, a year later..

Compare New York Rates

1. Enter travel information

City

2. Select websites to compare rates

Each selected website will open a new window.

New York Travel Deals