The hotel was okay. For the money, I would have expected nicer - some people complained that they didn't have air-conditioning in their rooms in the 90°F heat. And it was far from the main drag - I think next time we'll stay closer to the action. I also didn't like having to walk to the Wyndham Casa Marina for breakfast. The food was great there, but I like convenience.
However, I would recommend it if you are renting a car and plan on driving around the Keys since the parking was good. Since this is what we did, it was a great fit.
We loved Key West, which was part of our honeymoon trip. I would have loved to stay here longer than 3 days. It was good to relax here and have coffee (or a cocktail) on the deck or outside while watching the sun rise or set.