I recently spent a night at the Comfort Inn - Upper West Side. It was inexpensive, however unless budget is your primarily concern, I would NOT recommend this hotel. I found it to be dreary, cramped and overall depressing.
The lobby is small, but reasonably attractive and the front desk person who checked me in was friendly, explaining where I could find my complimentary breakfast the next morning. Still, when I asked for a non-smoking room with a king size bed, she explained that the hotel didn't have any king rooms (period) and instead, she gave me a choice of one bed or two. I said one and headed upstairs.
This Comfort Inn has only one elevator and it's both small and slow. W
...Read More
I recently spent a night at the Comfort Inn - Upper West Side. It was inexpensive, however unless budget is your primarily concern, I would NOT recommend this hotel. I found it to be dreary, cramped and overall depressing.
The lobby is small, but reasonably attractive and the front desk person who checked me in was friendly, explaining where I could find my complimentary breakfast the next morning. Still, when I asked for a non-smoking room with a king size bed, she explained that the hotel didn't have any king rooms (period) and instead, she gave me a choice of one bed or two. I said one and headed upstairs.
This Comfort Inn has only one elevator and it's both small and slow. When you reach your floor, you'll find fire doors to the right and left. On each side, there are only approximately four or five hotel rooms. Hallways are narrow, but clean.
My room made me laugh out loud: teeny-tiny and consumed by a double bed. At the foot of the bed, there was a small unusable desk. The room was so tight the chair couldn’t be pulled out from the desk.
There was a television mounted on a wall stand and one window. To the left, was the small, clean bathroom (shower, no tub).
Thinking that I could get a larger room by asking for a room with two beds, I took the long, slow ride down to the lobby.
My second room was on an even higher floor (Looooooooong elevator ride crammed in with a laundry cart full of sheets and towels). When I opened the door, I groaned. Immediately to the right was a twin bed. "Oh no," I thought, "are there two twin beds??" Taking a few steps into the narrow, oddly shaped room, I found a double bed wedged into an alcove of sorts. There was a narrow closet, a dresser holding a television at the foot of the bed and the bathroom. That was it.
For the price and location, I probably don't have any right to complain, but I will. Furnishings are shabby and the sheets and towels were downright threadbare. I didn't expect a view, but some natural light would have been nice. I definitely didn't want to put my bare feet on the carpet! Finally, and most importantly, I just didn't feel very safe here. When I went out to meet a friend for dinner, I was very worried about the belongings I left in my room. Fortunately, these safety concerns were unfounded.
One positive was the bathroom. Although small and featuring only a shower (no tub), the bathroom was brand new and spotless.
Other positives include a free breakfast (I didn't sample it though as I slept too late) and a great location near several subway lines, Central Park and lots of shopping/restaurants.
Still, would I stay here again? HELL, NO. Fans of hostels and budget motels may like it better than I did though.
Read Less