The word "romantic" doesn't do justice to the atmosphere at Flor de Sol. Imagine for a moment that you've traveled backward through time, and have arrived in the basement of a Spanish nobleman's castle – only you've brought a room full of black-clad, multiethnic young partygoers with you, and the prices are unmistakeably 21st century.
That's Flor de Sol, a bit of interior decorating magic on Greenwich St. High up in the rafters, crossed swords hang next to colorful banners, and metal sconces mounted high on crude wooden posts hold candles dripping with ambiance. The walls are primarily exposed brick (either very old or carefully distressed) with the occasional framed painting of a saint or a sunflower to brighten things up. The tables and chairs are somber in color and strict in line, creating a mood more like a depraved monastery than a cozy restaurant. Yet the overall feeling is convivial, festive, and above all bursting with the romance of a time and a place far, far away.
I wish I could say the same for the food. Perhaps I've been spoiled by my recent visit to Barcelona, but in my opinion, tapas should be small portions with proportionately small prices. At Flor de Sol, each plate of tapas cost more than I usually pay for my entire lunch. They were good, but not spectacular enough to justify the expense, in my opinion. Then again, there's a reason that the Zagat guide rates restaurants on price, service, and décor. It takes some combination of all three to be a success, and Flor definitely succeeded with their look. As for the service, it was perfectly fine: young, eager to please, and struggling with their English. The cost was absurd ($2.50 for about two shots of diet coke?!) but if you like the décor enough, it's a great place for a date, so who cares about the other criteria?
Some tapas to try, particularly if you're a vegetarian: Hongos Rellenos (stuffed mushrooms), Patatas Bravas (fiery sauce, yum!), Tortilla Espanola (like a quiche), Platanos al Gusto (translation, al garlic!), Vegetable Empanadillas Rellenas (yummy greens inside). If you're not a vegetarian, try anything with shrimp. The night we visited they had a delicious special of Camarones Salteados: brazilian shrimp sautéed with baby broccoli in wine sauce. The vegetarian paella also surprised me, mostly because it existed! but also because it was quite flavorful, considering that without the seafood, you're basically eating vegetables and rice.
Desserts were good but not to die for. The Pastel Tres Leches (three milk cake?!) sounded absolutely foul, but tasted pleasantly light and sweet. The wine list has some great Spanish selections, but the best thing at Flor de Sol is the fruity sangria. Romancers on a budget can order it at the bar and soak up the ambiance!