We opted on McCormick and Schmick's Seafood Restaurant because it was attached to our hotel (Westin) and because originally planned restaurant was not open yet.
We were greeted/sat within 5 minutes of entering the restaurant. We were seated at a booth that overlooked Fountain Square. The view was great, and we enjoyed both people watching and watching the horse carriages as they waited for patrons.
We were sat in a booth in the bar area that was beautiful. There was a stained glass window that featured a Cincinnati River view, and the Tiffany lamps over the bar featured UC, Xavier, and Bengals logo.
We were greeted by a server who took our drink orders, but were then served the rest of our meal by another server. Both servers were polite, but I felt that there were areas of service that lacked. We were having drinks with dinner and had to signal to our server when we were ready for refills. (I'm not talking about 30 seconds, I'm talking about several minutes with an empty glass sitting on the end of the table.)
We were a party of four, splitting the check between couples. My husband and I ordered a spinach and artichoke dip for an appetizer that was the best I've ever had. It was served with cooked pita break, and had a great flavor. Our friends ordered calamari, which they loved, but I was a little startled as I thought the red sauce was marinara -- it was cocktail sauce. (If you've followed any of my reviews, you may have realized that I am a little particular about my food. The cocktail sauce was a bit of a startle for me.) The rest of my dining party raved that it was the best calamari that they have had. I couldn't get over the cocktail sauce.
I had Alaskan King Crab Legs for dinner, which was perfectly prepared. I did make the mistake of ordering a full pound, which was too much. Luckily my husband helped me out. This is typically served with red potatoes and corn on the cob, but our server was very nice about subbing the corn on the cob for asparagus. My husband had the halibut, which had great presentation but lacked in taste for my husband. (Possibly a personal preference, but worth noting.)
When our order came, our crab leg order did not have the asparagus that we ordered, but once we pointed this out to our server, it was brought out quickly.
After our meals were finished, it took a while to get our check. This may have been because of the fact that 2 of us were still finishing our drinks, but in reality felt like we were just left sitting and waiting.
Our total tab, for 2 people with 2 drinks each was $91.97. The food was good, but I didn't feel like it was that good. I would have been much happier at the originally planned restaurant and spent $20 less, but then again, McCormick’s was open at 3pm, and I did get to people watch.
On the money saving side (which I am all about) McCormick & Schmicks does have a preferred guest membership program that allows you to earn points, which offers priority seating, a complimentary birthday entree, and several options to trade in points, ranging from free desert to an Oregon Wine Country trip. Note: joining costs $25, but you get a $25 dining certificate. I'm not sure that I'd join it, but if you like this restaurant, it's worth considering.
I don't regret eating here, but it was not the highlight that I hoped dinner would be. I would not tell someone that they should definitely go here, but if they told me that this is where they planned to eat I would not discourage them either. It was a good meal, not great, but my friends and I enjoyed each other's company with a good view.
by jmariep on April 6, 2009
McCormick & Schmick's Seafood
21 E 5th St Cincinnati, Ohio 45202
(513) 721-9339