Not knowing where the best dining places were located, we turned to the trusty Chamber of Commerce "Welcome to Eureka Springs" book. Since my husband was craving Italian, we chose a place that was said to the "the best Italian in Eureka Springs" and was said to have been nominated for great dining from Southern Living. Café Luigi was to be our first romantic dining experience of our get-a-away weekend.
I should have known something was amiss when we arrived and there was only one other couple in the entire restaurant and that we were not greeted at the door. We found a table next to the window after the waitress yelled from the kitchen to seat ourselves. The restaurant was divided into two small dining rooms but all does have great views of the street. The tablecloths were plastic and the chairs old and rickety. When our waitress arrived with our menus she was pleasant and polite. I asked for ice tea and was told the only tea they have was a cinnamon tea that many people didn’t like. Why would you have a tea as your only tea that most people didn’t like? She was right, it had a strong cinnamon taste, probably would have been good as a hot tea but not as a iced tea.
The menu comprised a good amount of options and sounded tasty. We chose the fried mushrooms with ranch dipping sauce as our appetizer. They were good, just like the ones I buy at our local freezer section. Mike chose the meat lasagna while I chose the cannelloni filled with spinach and topped with a white cream sauce. Our entrees were served with side salads and a breadstick, not the hot, fresh kind but a hard stick out of a package. The salad was nothing special and was served on a small saucer instead of a salad plate. I asked for the homemade creamy blue cheese dressing that came plopped on the salad because it was too thick to gently pour.
While Mike received his dinner, mine was served and was not what I asked for. My cannelloni was drenched with a red sauce. I pointed out the error; the waitress apologized and stated it was the owner’s mistake. After about 5 minutes I was served the correct dinner. It looked very appetizing but I soon found that looks can be deceiving. The white cream sauce had a strange taste somewhat like dirt and the cannelloni had freezer burn and was way too tough to cut with a fork. I am not sure what the filling consisted of but it was not what I expected. It was firm and grey with a horrible taste. Needless to say I could not finish the dinner. One more thing, the "homemade bread" was hardly homemade. It was at least a day old and stale.
While we sat at our table waiting for the poor food to come out of the kitchen, I distantly heard the ping of a microwave oven completing its cooking time. And while all of this disaster of a dinner was happening, the owner was walking around on the phone speaking loudly to whoever was on the other line. He did apologize about the mistake with my entrée stating there was a new cook. He told us this not once but at four different times. I have to think it was his excuse for his poor restaurant.
If I want to spend $45 for a dinner it will never be at Café Luigi again.
by VanessaK on November 24, 2008
Cafe Luigi
91 S Main St Eureka Springs, Arkansas 72632
(479) 253-6888