Located on Route One in Old Saybrook Nancy’s restaurant has an interesting history. For several years a very upscale restaurant called Rosemary and Sage occupied the building where Nancy’s Restaurant is. The one night a car drove through the building. Luckily no one was killed but the building sat empty and battered looking for over a year. When it first reopened it was still called Rosemary and Sage but featured a new menu and before long a new addition to the name "Nancy’s".
This is a beautiful restaurant with warm gold walls, crisp white linens and real napkins. All the tables gave oil burning candles and fresh flowers. There is a very nice wooden bar where you can eat or drink and a more formal dining-room. This evening we sat in the dining-room. It was a Monday night at around 7:30pm and it was dead all over town, we had the whole room to ourselves.
Because of the circumstances service was flawless but I have to say I have eaten here several times before and service has always been stellar. You have the choice of ordering from the dinner menu or from the grill menu. The grill menu offers smaller portions and more casual meals.
We began our meal with the lobster and artichoke fondue. Well not really , we began with the bread basket and stuffed our face with the buttery garlic bread. The fondue came served in a ramekin with real discernible chunks of lobster claw meat and creamy artichoke. It was surrounded by toasted Italian bread triangles. We made short work of it I can tell you and it was outstanding.
For my main course I ordered the Riviera pear salad. Fresh greens are covered with slices of pear, Gorgonzola cheese and candied walnuts. Around the side are Bermuda onion slices, diced tomatoes and thick cucumber slices. It is served with a balsamic vinaigrette and honey. It was a heaping plate full and the different flavors and textures are perfectly balanced.
Al chose one of the specials, a tenderloin club sandwich. Slices of fillet with lettuce and tomato on toasted bread. A heaping pile of french fries filled the center of the plate and also a small container of coleslaw. Al asked for it medium rare and it was cooked perfectly and was of such a generous size that he took home two of the four quarters.
What we could have ordered.
Appetizers:
Pan Bronzed Mozzarella
Clams Casino
Chicken Liver Pate
Sirloin Carpaccio
Scallops Rumaki
Soups:
French Onion
New England Clam Chowder
Scallop and red bell pepper bisque
roasted tomato and garlic
Entrées:
NY Strip
Beef Wellington
Filet Mignon
Lobster Madeira
Scallops Dore
Jumbo lump crab cakes
Linguini Pescatore
Scampi Blanco
Stuffed jumbo prawns
Chicken Parm
The desserts are all made on site and include carrot cake, chocolate mousse, caramel crunch cheese cake, and apple crisp.