Luaus are always great, but some are better than others. The first luau I ever went to was on Oahu, and it was better than this one. This luau was fine, but the bar had only two lines, and they were each about 30 people deep each time you wanted to get a drink. The dancers were fantastic and the women were beautiful, which was greatly appreciated by my teenage son and I. He got to take a photo with a lovely Hawaiian woman who was just about his height, and the photo turned out great.
The backdrop was on the ocean of Waikoloa Bay, which was just incredible. The first part was a bit tough, though, because the blazing sun was just beating down on us with no reprieve. It wasn't until sundown that the atmosphere became more comfortable.
We couldn't upgrade like in other luaus, and everyone had to settle for buffet style. I always pay the extra for VIP seating if available, but that was not an option. This way, servers will bring your food and drinks and you don't have to wait in the lines. You also get to sit up front, though this was not really an issue, because the seats at this luau were fine. We did meet a nice family from New York and we had a good time.
If I were to go back, I would try another luau just to see if I liked it better.