Of all the fine dining in Seaport Village, this one is probably my favorite. Then again, it's not that hard to become my favorite, the restaurant must simply have the best fish and chips over and extremely long time (i.e., they must taste the same after my 4-year hiatus from the village). That said this restaurant does indeed have the best fish and chips. The best I’ve ever eaten? No, not quite, that honor goes to the Yorkshire Fish Shop in EPCOT, but the Edgewater grill is much less expensive all things considered.
One of my other favorite things is the view. While it lacks the over the water views of the San Diego Pier Café, it offers a nice view of the water and an even nicer view of the boardwalk and all the people passing by. If you can wait for patio or at the very least near patio seating, do so, it’s worth the wait.
However, this restaurant isn’t without its problems. Service is lack luster; we were offered another table’s diner all evening, then given their much pricier bill. And the Mahi Mahi with the mango salsa was dry and flavorless, a disappointment for an expensive item especially for a restaurant near the ocean that specializes in seafood. I expect that quality in Tucson, but not in San Diego.
Overall though, this is the best fine dining with a view in Seaport Village. Just stick to the fish and chips, or possibly the pizza (though I couldn’t have any, my little brothers cheese pizza looked amazing!), and you’ll be fine. Don’t forget to walk in with slightly lowered standards—this is a tourist destination, this is not the place to get a taste of local San Diego cuisine. With that in mind, try it out. This restaurant and the village is within walking distance of many hotels, save the money you would have spent on parking and use it in the shops.