If your grandmother was Italian, and ran a restaurant, it is pretty likely she would create something pretty similar to Maggiano’s Little Italy. Although Maggiano’s is a chain restaurant (part of Brinker International, who also own Chili’s and Romano's Macaroni Grill), it features huge portions of high-quality food at very reasonable prices.
There isn’t a lot of flash or sizzle at Maggiano’s; you will likely recognize every single dish on the menu. They offer a variety of fresh-baked breads, appetizers, pastas and sauces, chicken dishes, and "meatier" fare (steaks, chops, and veal), all augmented by a very serviceable wine list and full bar. The pasta options and cooked-to-order style make Maggiano’s a good option for vegetarians (unless of course you are going low or no carb). For larger parties (10 or more), a family-style menu of selected items is offered.
Here are some recently sampled entrees.
Chicken Vesuvio: A mix of drumsticks and breasts (on the bone), with the requisite potato wedges and peas, browned in a mix of garlic, olive oil, white wine, and oregano. It is generally accepted that chicken Vesuvio originated in Chicago, and it has become a staple of many local restaurants. While very good, other restaurants in Chicago (in particular Harry Caray’s) do a better job of producing this favorite.
Lasagna: You know it well--wide, wavy pasta strips layered with ricotta cheese and meat sauce. This slice stands at least 4 inches high on the piping hot plate and swims in marinara sauce, offered with meat or without (the lasagna itself has meat). Very good for dinner (and lunch the next day, and dinner again the day after).
"Rigatoni D:" Roasted, boneless chicken and mushrooms are mixed in with rigatoni, and served in a cream Marsala sauce. The mushrooms (bite size) are very good, as is the chicken. This dish might be more interesting if the Marsala sauce was served traditional, not creamy. While not nearly as heavy as Alfredo sauce, the Marsala definitely lost a little zing with the cream base. Still very tasty of course.
Pesto Linguine: Chunks of boneless chicken and a scattering of pine nuts complement the pesto linguine. This dish is outstanding: the pesto sauce is consistently fresh and the chicken is very moist and tender. The pine nuts add some texture and taste.
Filet Mignon: Checking in at close to $30 for the large cut, this steak is a monster. It is served without pretense: it arrives sizzling in its own juices, sprinkled with just a thin layer of onion strings as an accompaniment. It really doesn’t need anything else, but remember, butterflying is for wimps.