New York City Hotels

A July 2004 trip to New York by NYCtraveler

Holiday Inn DowntownMore Photos

NYC has a wide range of accommodations, from top-notch, five-star hotels to super budget stays! Here are some hotels I have visited recently.

  • 10 reviews
  • 17 photos
What makes the Broadway Plaza stand out from the competition? Affordably priced, clean, larger than average rooms (by NYC standards). There’s even complimentary continental breakfast every morning. I avoided the attached restaurant, however, because its deli-style counter service and oddball mix of bagels and burritos didn’t appeal to me.

Located in Chelsea, the Plaza is central to all downtown and midtown attractions. This accessibility gave me a wonderful all-around experience and a good overview of the city. It was a nice walk to Greenwich Village, especially when window-shopping on 5th Avenue along the way. And a quick train ride brought me up to Times Square to catch a Broadway show.

As for the nightlife, Chelsea is well known for trendy clubs and an ultra-hip gay scene. There’s plenty of local culture to soak in after dark.

Because the Plaza is jammed onto a very busy street, make sure to keep your eyes open or you just might miss out on a great deal.

  • Member Rating 4 out of 5 by NYCtraveler on July 12, 2004

Broadway Plaza Hotel
1155 BROADWAY New York, New York 10001
212-679-7665

Holiday Inn Downtown NYCBest of IgoUgo

Hotel | "Holiday Inn Downtown"

Holiday Inn Downtown
Located at the crossroads of Soho, Chinatown and Little Italy, Holiday Inn Downtown is the perfect location for exploring lower Manhattan.

The diversity of Canal Street—and all its affordable wares—and the excitement of fashionable Soho are right outside your door. You can shop till you drop, then top it all off with dinner in Little Italy, which offers some of the city’s best food at affordable prices.

I never ran out of things to do or see in this area. From the hotel, it’s a scenic walk to South Street Seaport or the heart of Greenwich Village, and just a quick cab ride to Wall Street, Battery Park and the Statue of Liberty. As a younger traveler, I liked how close it was to a plethora of eclectic hangouts on the Lower East Side and in the East Village.

But this hotel offers more than just a great location. All the rooms have been newly renovated and have state-of-the-art cordless telephones (even in the bathrooms!) and CD players. The lobby even has two kiosks with high-speed Internet access.

Also in the lobby, there’s a small bar/lounge and a sit-down restaurant called the Pacifica. Reflecting the diversity of the area, the restaurant serves traditional Cantonese dishes as well as some American fare.

The staff at the front desk is friendly and helpful, and there are security guards located at the main entrance, even though the area is pretty safe.

All in all, the Holiday Inn Downtown is a real find!

  • Member Rating 4 out of 5 by NYCtraveler on July 12, 2004

Holiday Inn Downtown NYC
138 LAFAYETTE STREET New York, New York 10013
212-966-8898

Howard Johnson's
The Howard Johnson at Penn Station is a centrally located, inexpensive place to stay (keep in mind that "budget" for NYC usually hovers around $100 a night for a standard room). Although it’s pretty basic and compact, you can’t beat the area. Chances are you won’t spend much time in your room anyway once you get caught up in the city’s hustle and bustle.


If you’re lucky enough to snag a street view, you’ll probably be able to see Madison Square Garden from your window—watch out though, I’m sure it can get quite noisy. And the Empire State Building and Times Square are just a few blocks away.


When you get worn out from all the walking and want to sit back and relax, one of the city’s best movie theaters is just a block away. I like the brand-new Loews 34th Street because it offers something for everyone—stadium/priority seating and both first-run blockbusters and independent films.


For those on a tight budget, this HoJo’s provides complimentary continental breakfast. It also has free juice and coffee 24 hours a day. While I was there, though, a couple of the machines were broken and the doors to the dining area were locked after breakfast. But, hey, just do what I did—take your coffee with you and go explore the city some more!

  • Member Rating 3 out of 5 by NYCtraveler on July 12, 2004

New Yorker HotelBest of IgoUgo

Hotel | "New Yorker (Ramada) Hotel"

The New Yorker
The New Yorker is literally a feast for the senses! There are tons of things to do—enjoy dinner and drinks at La Vigna or even do some shopping—and the lobby is always buzzing with visitors from all over the world.

Sipping coffee at the café and people watching was something I really enjoyed doing while I was there. And the helpful "Theatre & Tour" desk had everything I needed in order to make the most of my time in the city.

Downstairs, away from the hubbub, there was a fitness room, laundromat and 24-hour business center, which had a computer with Internet access, a fax machine and a copier. Strict security at the elevators kept random visitors from roaming the floors.

My only complaint is that the lobby was so busy at times, individualized service was scarce. I waited an eternity to ask someone a question at the front desk. But luckily, I forgot all about that once I hit the city streets.

Not only is the New Yorker a great hotel, its location can’t be beat. I was within walking distance to many major attractions, including Madison Square Garden, the Empire State building, Times Square/Theater District and all sorts of shopping.

  • Member Rating 4 out of 5 by NYCtraveler on July 12, 2004

New Yorker Hotel
481 Eighth Avenue New York, New York 10001
(212) 971-0101

Windsor
Located off the beaten path, the Windsor Hotel is the place to stay if you’re interested in getting to know Chinatown and the Lower East Side. This one’s for locals and thrill-seekers only!

The hotel is very small and basic, but also rather new (it opened in 2001). It is near Soho, Little Italy and the Financial District, and the subway is extremely close by. I liked it because it’s near the East Village, which has a lot of cool bars and restaurants.

I didn’t see it, but the hotel apparently has a large penthouse suite with a Jacuzzi and private rooftop. I bet the view from up there is great!

Although it’s adjacent to some interesting sites, the Windsor’s location leaves much to be desired. I wouldn’t recommend staying here if you are a single traveler who’s never been to New York.

  • Member Rating 2 out of 5 by NYCtraveler on July 12, 2004

Windsor Hotel
108 Forsyth Street New York, New York 10002
(212) 226-3009

The Carlton On Madison AvenueBest of IgoUgo

Hotel | "The Carlton"

Carlton
"Madison Avenue" has long been synonymous with influential advertisers and the power elite who decide what’s "in." The Carlton on Madison Avenue offers a nice contrast to that mentality—extreme tranquility that’s conveniently located.

Snuggled between Murray Hill and Gramercy Park, the hotel is surrounded by tree-lined streets and historic buildings. And many of the city’s major attractions are just a stroll away.

I found it very relaxing that the guest room mixed mahogany furniture and soothing colors. The bathroom was marble and rather spacious. Many of the rooms have a nice view of the Empire State Building, which is just a few blocks away.

The exterior is beautiful; the elaborate architecture only adds to the charm of the neighborhood. The aesthetics are only slightly spoiled by the fact that the building is currently undergoing a multimillion-dollar restoration.

The outgoing staff reassured me that everything should be completed sometime this year, and I was also told a little about what was being done. A new wing will include an atrium with a waterfall—right now the lobby is on the small side but because it’s ensconced in glass and mirrors, it has an airy feel—a health club/spa and a four-star restaurant/bar. All this is more than enough reason for me to return!

  • Member Rating 4 out of 5 by NYCtraveler on July 12, 2004

The Carlton On Madison Avenue
22 E 29TH ST New York, New York 10016
212-532-4100

The MarcelBest of IgoUgo

Hotel

The Marcel
At first I couldn't find the Marcel. It had a rather nondescript exterior and wasn't clearly marked. Once I stepped through the doors, though, I really took a liking to its coziness and art deco style.

The mod lobby had a small alcove library with a TV. There was a complimentary cappuccino machine—if you’re a night owl, like me, it’s good to know it’s available 24 hours a day. And no matter what time it was, the staff at the front desk was more than helpful.

Although the guestroom was small, it was clean and comfy. There wasn’t much of a view though. I had a choice between a room overlooking an adjoining rooftop or construction. I chose construction, because at least I overlooked the street.

Located just a few blocks from Union Square, which has the city’s biggest Farmer’s Market, the Marcel is truly a hidden gem.

  • Member Rating 3 out of 5 by NYCtraveler on July 15, 2004

The Marcel
201 EAST 24 STREET New York, New York 10011
212-696-3800

Tribeca Grand
The Tribeca Grand is not just a place to stay--it’s an experience unto itself. If I were rich like Paris Hilton, I’d totally live there!

First of all, you can’t beat Tribeca, literally the TRiangle BElow CAnal. It’s a hip, affluent, and artistic area that’s also laid back, relatively quiet, and close to all sorts of things to do. But most importantly, the hotel itself has plenty to do and offers a lot of eye candy. You could avoid the outside world for a week and still have a blast!

Everything is very modern and comfortable, and the décor is spot on. My room (a standard) was very cozy, and the bathroom was amazing! There were tons of amenities at my fingertips, including a fax machine and all sorts of goodies (snacks, disposable cameras, even Tribeca Grand T-shirts and caps).

The hallway outside my room overlooked the atrium. The design gave the hotel an outdoorsy, airy feel (if you are afraid of heights, though, I wouldn’t recommend the higher floors).

On nights and weekends, this hotel becomes an uber trendy hang out. Trinity restaurant and the Church lounge can get really packed. The Tribeca Grand also has screening rooms and is home to many Tribeca Film Festival events. But don’t worry, all rooms have sound barriers so you can still get a good night’s rest.

I just can’t say enough positive things about this place! If you have the money, it’s a must when visiting NYC.

  • Member Rating 5 out of 5 by NYCtraveler on July 15, 2004

Tribeca Grand Hotel
TWO AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS New York, New York 10013
212-519-6600

The New York Helmsley is a top-notch hotel located in Midtown. It’s just a few blocks from the United Nations, Grand Central Station, Times Square, and the Theater District. I was right near the heart of everything!

The lobby was rather spacious, and the staff was friendly and helpful with everything from transportation/directions to theater tickets.

There’s a huge restaurant called Mindy’s, and Harry’s Bar serves drinks till late. Hotel security was pretty good, with a 24-hour doorman on duty.

The room décor was a bit reminiscent of my grandmother’s house in the late ’70s/early ’80s—not the greatest aesthetic, but it made me feel at home.

  • Member Rating 3 out of 5 by NYCtraveler on July 15, 2004

The New York Helmsley
212 EAST 42ND STREET New York, New York 10017
212-490-8900

Clarion Hotel Park AvenueBest of IgoUgo

Hotel | "The Clarion Park Avenue"

Clarion
Like many NYC hotels, the Clarion doesn’t look like much from the outside. But this newly renovated hotel has a lot to offer, especially for the price.

Although the hallways are extremely narrow and the rooms are close together, everything is quite clean, and I had all the basics. There was even a breakfast café in the lobby!

I was happy to be in the heart of the Fashion District, and just five blocks or so from the Empire State Building, Macy’s and Herald Square. On a nice day, I even walked to Times Square. There was a subway station just a block away, so I had easy access to all of the city’s attractions.

  • Member Rating 4 out of 5 by NYCtraveler on July 15, 2004

Clarion Hotel Park Avenue
429 PARK AVENUE SOUTH New York, New York 10016
212-532-4860

About the Writer

NYCtraveler
NYCtraveler
New York, New York

Get the Word Out

Share this travel journal beyond IgoUgo with your favorite sharing tools.