The folks at 4th Street Bistro really try hard to get it right. The dining rooms are lovely and the wait staff is very professional, friendly and helpful, but unfortunately, the kitchen just doesn't have the skills to make this the top-flight restaurant it aspires to be. The food is good, but not great.
On one recent visit, I had an appetizer of fig stuffed with goat cheese, wrapped in proscutto and grilled. It was an interesting combination, but the proscutto didn't add any flavor, and the portion was simply too small to justify the $8 price. My main course was Niman Ranch (very classy beef purveyer) beef shortribs. Although it had obviously been braised a long time, it was just salty, with none of the rich flavors I had expected. My husband's lamb shank had the same problem -- too much salt, too little other flavor.
On another recent visit, I had scallops with butternut squash and porcini mushroom risotto. The scallops, which had been coated in a light breading, were browned almost to the point of being too brown but they were still tender and moist inside. The accompanying risotto was excellent. A friend had halibut, which didn't impress her. She suspected it had been frozen because the texture was a bit mushy. Desserts also sounded better than they tasted. The wine list is very good, with some unusual selections by the glass.
Don't get me wrong, the food is good, it's just not special, though certainly not due to a lack of effort on the part of everyone at the restaurant.