Wright is Wrong
Chapter One: The Greatest Building Never Constructed (in Salem)
Once a newspaper in a, relatively, small town, in need of new housing for its operations, approached a noted architect asking if he would design this for them. After a time he offered them a preliminary, but radically new, design. It would consist, in part, of columns arranged in a sort of forest, which would reverse-taper from a narrow bottom upwards to splay into largish circular dishes, supporting the upper floors while creating a large open space about their bases. The newspaper was impressed.
The noted architect came to the, relatively, small town to view the site, finish his visualization and finalize his design. Arriving to meet the newspaper's representatives, he announced he’d found a better location for his radically new design and that this was where they would build.
"Oh, no, we can't. We don't own the property," they told him.
"Never mind that," he replied, "just buy the land."
"We can't buy a public greenspace."
"But that’s the only place I’ll consent to construct my radically new design in your town," he informed them.
"It's one of the city's oldest parks! It’s the largest park. It gets used a good bit. We can't buy it!"
"Well, then," said the noted architect, "if I can't build my radically new design there I won't build it for you at all."
And he left.
You couldn't argue with the man. He once told a client complaining of a leaking roof: "Madam, that is how you know it is a roof." (The exchange above is a fictionalization of fact, save the last bit, which is an actual quote.)
Some time later he took his radically new design, slightly re-imagined, to a new client, who was impressed. Dubious local authorities forced him to pile sandbags onto a mockup column proving each could actually bear the load claimed. They were impressed. Where upon The SC Johnson Wax building, in Racine, Wisconsin, became one more item on the list of buildings designed by Frank Lloyd Wright with construction completed in the three-dimensional world. And everyone was impressed.
The Capital Journal had to go elsewhere for the design of their new facility.
All because Frank was such a martinet.
And yes, Bush's Pasture Park is still one of Salem's largest (now third in size to Minto-Brown Island Park’s 900-acres and Wallace Marine Park‘s 114.5), and it still gets used a good bit.
Chapter Two: Insults to Injury?
Once, like a lot of places, Salem had more than one daily newspaper, it had two. The Capital Journal and the Oregon Statesman.
The Oregon Statesman?! Yes, the same one founded by Asahel Bush II back in Oregon City in 1851, which he had moved to Salem in 1853. The same Asahel whose family had donated the then 57 acres of land making up the park, which was named in his honor, to the city for the express purpose of a park in 1917. Very insulting indeed to build a competing paper’s facility upon that land which also sat immediately adjacent to the property upon which he lived. Would Frank have cared about that? Probably not.
But Asahel had sold the Oregon Statesman in 1863. And by 1932, the year in which these events took place, Asahel had been dead for something like 19 years, give or take a few months and a few days. He was obviously well beyond caring. So the irony of the situation is only apparent and not actual, although Asahel’s daughters Sally and Eugenia did still live in Bush House on what remained of the family farm, which would later become part of "the" park as well.
Chapter Three: Sleeping With the Enemy
Once, both papers were very partisan as established.
--The Oregon Statesman (1851) was very much the Democratic mouthpiece.
--The Capital Journal (1888) was founded to further the Republican cause.
But both papers passed into the hands of others and their original affiliations became blurred.
Sidebar: The Portland based Oregonian was more interested in the Whig agenda.
Eventually the Statesman came into the possession of Charles Sprague (he continued publishing during his term as Oregon’s Governor 1939-1943 ... hmm) and the Journal had passed to Bernard Mainwaring. Since the former was a morning paper, while the later was afternoon, the two men decided to use the same facility for publication while maintaining independent staff and content. So the two papers began a joint domicile arrangement. Like sailors aboard a submarine they hot bunked, each having use of the press while the other wasn’t using it.
In 1973 the two companies began a merger to become part of Gannett Company Incorporated.
Ultimately the two papers merged completely as well, and in 1980 the Capital Journal and the Oregon Statesman became the Statesman Journal, which is still published today.
So perhaps it would not have been as inappropriate for the Journal to have been published on former Bush land as it first may have seemed, in the long run, but who could have known that at the time? Anyway, it’s much nicer as a park. Makes a much better story too.
Chapter Four: What Goes Around -- Comes Back to Where it Started
The only Frank Lloyd Wright design that was ever actually constructed in Oregon is the Gordon House, which is now on the grounds of the Oregon Garden in Silverton southeast of Salem.
Frank had designed the house for a site in Wilsonville, a suburb of Portland, in 1957, but it wasn’t built until 1964. By that time Wright had been dead for 4 years. Time passed and as is its tendency was rather unkind to the Gordon House. Unlived in and unloved, or so it seemed until the threat of imminent demolition was raised. This resulted in the house being, after various other contending suggestions were eliminated, sold, partially dismantled and transported to a new location. There, in a terrain that it was not specifically designed for even though the general consensus was that it was appropriate, it was reconstructed, rehabilitated and opened to the public. Wonder what Frank would have made of that?
Resources -- Tours and Other Weblinks:
My Journal: Bush's Pasture Park: (A)sahel to Ga(Z)ebos
--------------------------------------------
Bush's Pasture Park
Open 5am to midnight.
--------------------------------------------
Bush House Tours
600 Mission Street SE, Salem, Oregon, 97301
503-363-4714, bushhouse@salemart.org
Adults $4, seniors/students $3, children (6-12) $2
--Tues-Sun (Oct-Apr) 2pm-5pm, (May-Sept) 12pm-5pm. Last tour begins: 4.30pm
--------------------------------------------
Statesman Journal Tours
Includes among other things: the publisher's office, circulation, advertising, the newsroom, and the printing press.
280 Church Street NE, Salem, Oregon, 97301
503-399-6673
--Duration: 1 hour.
--Thursdays: 3.30pm, Friday: 1.30pm
Use the online form to request a booking.
--------------------------------------------
Gordon House, (at the Oregon Garden) Tours
879 West Main Street, PO Box 155, Silverton, Oregon, 97381
503-874-6006
toll free: 877-674-2733 ext. 6006
gordonhouse@oregongarden.org
Group Tour information (Pat Deede): 503-874-8249.
--Tours at top of each hour 10am-5pm March-October, 10am-3pm November-February
--Self-guided brochure tour, first floor only: $2
--Guided tour of both floors: $5
--In-Depth Guided tours, the first Saturday of each month at 11am, reservation needed: $15
Tour fees are in addition to Garden admission fees:
--Adults: $5.00
--Seniors (60+) $4.00
--Students (8 -17) $4.00
--Children (under 8) Free
--------------------------------------------
Links:
--Society of Architectural Historians "Frank Lloyd Wright's Design for the Capital Journal, Salem, Oregon (1932)" by Donald Leslie Johnson, "Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 55.1" (March 1996) The article itself isn’t online.
--SCJW Administration Building and Research Tower Writing Portfolio site. A history of the design, without noting why it wasn’t built.
--SC Johnson Wax Building Wright in Wisconsin site.
--Johnson Wax BuildingGreat Buildings Online site. Downloadable 3-D model.
--Frank Lloyd Wright, A Film by Ken Burns More background information on Wright.
--Statesman Journal History
--Charles A. Sprague Oregon State Archives site.