Joey's was really hopping the night of our arrival on Marco Island.
Hoping to find a good place for Italian, we leafed through dining brochures in our timeshare's office. The two places we picked happened to be closed, as September is the slow season.
"Hey," my daughter called from the back seat of the car, "What about that Joey place we passed before the bridge?"
No one had even noticed it, but we dutifully headed back toward the Marco Bridge.
We thought we might have to wait for a table, but an affable hostess seated us immediately.
It was hard to choose from the many offerings, but after being nudged a few times by my better half, the decision was made.
We ordered stuffed shells in marinara sauce, spaghetti and meatballs, chicken Parmigiana, and my sister-in-law and I opted to share a mushroom and sausage pizza.
Our server was affable and attentive. When ordering the pizza, we told her we wanted the large since we were REALLY hungry. She advised us against us, saying the regular pizza was quite large. We trusted her.
Salads arrived first for those who ordered a non-pizza entree. They consisted of mainly iceberg lettuce, red onion rings, olives, and tomatoes. The house dressing was unmemorable, but for those who requested oil and vinegar, cruets arrived with light green extra virgin olive oil and a fine balsamic vinegar, which elevated the pedestrian salad to enticing heights.
All 3 entrees came swathed in the same, garlicky marinara sauce. The chicken Parmigiana was a generous portion with spaghetti on the side. Plenty of cheese cloaked the entree. The stuffed shells sported the same mantel of melted mozzarella. The shells were properly al dente, while the ricotta filling was nicely firm and spiked with Parmesan for added flavor. The meatballs that accompanied the spaghetti were nothing extraordinary, and tasted like the frozen, bagged variety. The spaghetti was al dente. The real star arrived after the entrees, however. If you stay anywhere in Marco or Naples, do NOT miss the thick-crust pizza! To say that the toppings were abundant would be understatement. Just enough sauce to bind everything together lent a key element to the delicious flavor. And the cheese! It was gloriously thick and melted, running almost Vesuvially when cut. As predicted, we couldn't come close to finishing. This pizza heated up as good as new in the microwave, making at least three lunches during the week.
The service was good, but not the best. Our server was helpful when asked, but not overly cordial, and not good with refills.
The tab came to around $90 for 5, including tax, tip, and 3 sodas and 2 draught beers.
So it's mixed bag here. The entrees, while good, were nothing remarkable. My recommendation is to bypass the pasta and go for the pizza. You won't be disappointed!