Indianapolis is not particularly known for its
haute couteur, but we do at least make a stab at metropolitan living now and again. Nicky Blaine's is one of those. It's located downtown, just on the south side of Monument Circle (very nearly at the intersections of Washington and Meridian) in the historic Nat Cole Building. Parking is difficult downtown, but I'd recommend the Sun Garage in the Circle Centre Mall just immediately south and west of Nicky Blaine's on Washington (very cheap, very safe, and easy access to most of downtown's offerings).
Nicky Blaine's has made a valiant effort at being high class. Unfortunately, they overplayed their hand a bit. The mahogany-and-brass panelling and bar are very nice, and the basement location in the Nat Cole Building is very intimate, giving the place a warm, friendly environ. However, the accoutrements are a little cliché and overbearing. Where most places have crown molding, Nicky Blaine's has a continuous runner of fake ferns. About 1/3 of these would have make the place elegant, but as it stands, it borderlines on pastichy jungle life. The absense of overhead lighting is very welcome, as the ever-present 40-watt bulbs give the bar just the right ambient light level. The furniture is ecclectic and nice, but looks like it was mostly picked up at some wealthy dowager's estate sale (i.e., it's a bit threadbare and dated). You will enjoy yourself most @ Nicky Blaine's in a party of 4 or more, sitting comfortably around a large round table or at a conversational cluster of couches.
My main draw? The martinis! I'd like to think I'm a connoisseur of the art of the martini, so this is one of my favorite places. The names alone are drool-worthy: Vanilla Sex Martinis, City Nights Martinis, Chocolate Martinis, and my personal fav, the Espresso Martinis. Of course, they serve all the classics of this drink genre: Straight, Dry, and Dirty Martinis, Cosmopolitans, Lemon Drops, and Apple Martinis. All of these are made with the finest liquors, and served with visual taste and style. To my knowledge, they don't water any of their liquors, so make sure to have a designated driver at the ready, because these drinks are STRONG.
Dress at Nicky Blaine's is just shy of formal. I usually feel comfortable in a nice pair of khakis and a turtleneck sweater, and most women will be at ease in a nice (but not over-the-top) cocktail dress. The waitresses are chic and pretentious in a very fun sort of way, and the rituals of serving are great. Order a pack of cigarettes if you smoke, and a waitress will serve it to you on a silver platter, open, packed, with one cigarette presented with a lipstick print on the filter. I thought it was funny, anyway.
If you have a little extra money to spend, and a change of nice clothes, check this place out!