The Old Post Office Restaurant is the place to visit for an evening of a traditional Fish Boil. Be sure to arrive early to watch outdoors behind the restaurant the "boil fish master" create the "boil over," which signals that the catch is ready to serve. The menu for this traditional feast included boiled whitefish, small red potatoes, small white onions, a variety of fresh homemade lemon, pumpkin, and rye breads. For dessert their fresh baked cherry pie should not be passed over.
Be sure to get a window seat or request outdoor seating, if the weather permits, to enjoy Door County's beautiful sunset overlooking Eagle Harbor. A word to the wise: whitefish has lots of bones so be sure to take special care to eat slowly and carefully.