This place serves Guinness on tap - that's the only kind of beer on tap there. You can opt for a small selection of other bottled beers or a drink from the full bar.
The draw for Paddy Reilly's is the live Irish music that begins around 10pm. However, it drew almost no one. I enjoyed having the place almost to myself. I could really hear the music and enjoy a leisurely conversation without having to shout.
It feels more like a neighborhood spot than a destination. The place is extremely casual, so you'll feel right at home in a pair of old jeans.
Check out for more information. Also you can call ahead at 212/686-1210 to find out show information.