Results 1-2of 2 Reviews
Mine Hill, New Jersey
June 19, 2004
From journal 2004 Bahamas Harborside At Atlantis
Cortlandt Manor, New York
May 19, 2004
I guess I'd give this place a mixed review. Prices were reasonable, our food was decent, but the service was dreadfully slow and somewhat indifferent. Several tables near us left before their waitress ever showed up because they overheard other tables complaining.
A table near us also complained their food was cold, but ours was moderately warm. The real saving grace to Choosy Foods is their fresh squeezed orange juice. We were surprised how little fresh fruit there is on the island and all other orange juice we tasted was either from concentrate and came watery out of a drink machine or was Tropicana cartons at outrageous prices (over $8 for a half gallon at the grocery store). At Choosy Foods, it was the real thing and very sweet. The owner apparently squeezes it herself and they often run out so they don't advertise it too highly, but if you're in need of an orange juice fix, this is the place (I think it was $2.50 a glass).
From journal Family-Friendly Atlantis