We told our front desk clerk that we wanted to go out for a "nice" dinner and this is the place he recommended.
Unfortunately, he forgot to mention that reservations are highly recommended, in fact we had to wait 2 hours (during which time I had my hair braided) for a table on a weeknight. The hostess wasn’t going to let us in until I told her that we had been sent there by our hotel and just spent 10 dollars on a cab to get there.
It is easy to reach in Port Lucaya and has a nice atmosphere. There won't be all that many places where you don't have to sit in a plastic chair for dinner. We had the lobster, which was excellent and very nice sized. They also seemed to specialize in pizza, as that is what most people were ordering.
I wouldn't attempt to get in on a weekend without reservations. The place was completely packed when we walked by at 10:30 at night.