If you're looking for an upscale dining experience, there seem to be only three places to go in Playa Hermosa: Ginger, La Finisterra, and Villa del Sueno. We decided not to try hiking in the dark up the rather treacherous-looking hill that leads up to La Finisterra and had our last night's splurge at Villa del Sueno.
Upon arrival, we were immediately asked whether we had reservations--the only time we were ever asked that in Playa Hermosa, and it pretty much sets the tone for the place. The restaurant was the best (real French service!) and the most expensive we visited. The menu was varied, but it pretty much all fit into the French-continental mold: shrimp cocktails, coq au vin, filet mignon... a kind of 1960s ideal of fine dining. No fish and rice here! The wine list was short, but the wonder was that they actually had one.
We both ordered the filet mignon. Made with local Brahman beef, it was extremely tender and tasty.
Desserts included items such as chocolate cake and profiteroles. The profiteroles were pleasant but disappointingly filled with ice cream instead of custard, with even more ice cream on the side. The owner conceded that it wasn't very authentic, but he said that American tourists love lots of ice cream.
For entertainment, the Quebecois owner performs with his band a couple of nights a week. The staff was very attentive, if a bit nervous about keeping up the high tone.