Tomatino's Pizza, formerly Jan's Pizza, was Tyler and Allen's first go at owning a restaurant. Both guys, described earlier in regard to the Olive Room, started out flipping pizzas at Jan's, a favorite of nearby Huntingdon College. When they bought it, they super-charged it, hired a bunch of young, hip employees and began to sell beer, calzones, fresh breads, and pizza. The pizza is very good and nouveau and you can get anything from old favorites to new twists, like The Cali with all California-style veggies.
The atmosphere is very warm and homey, but there are, like Olive Room, only about ten tables, so a wait will probably be necessary. Take-outs are available, but not deliveries. Despite being owned and operated by young people, the place is very fast and efficient and will quell any notions some people may have about such an environment.