The location is perfect, with views of the sunsets over Frenchmen’s Cay and St. Thomas if you choose the outdoor patio or get the right window seat.
The food was fresh, with most interest being in the citrus seafood dishes. The menu gave us all plenty to choose from. The bar is THE place to hang. Get a Painkiller and keep the tin cup—an easy souvenir decision.
The highly advertised rum was okay, but we had other favorites. I'll leave it to you to explore and decide for yourself. That's more than half the fun.
The bar can be quite an event in itself, with rum drinks like the famous Painkiller served in various potencies. Careful, they can sneak up on you.
Service was a little better than "island time." Most meals, but not all, were delivered as ordered.
Prices were probably a little higher than you would pay in many other places in the area for the same basic meal. However, the small premium is justified by the special ambience.