Casey's is the more casual sister restaurant to Gaido's next door. The food is virtually the same, but the atmosphere is more relaxed, and the prices are much reduced. We ate our Thanksgiving dinner here, and we loved it.
Our waiter (Oleg) was very professional and helpful, and his Russian accent was charming. We began our dinner with a fresh green salad topped with a delicious honey pecan vinegrette, and accompanied by fresh bread. We shared a combo plate of fried shrimp and the daily catch, which served two generously. The shrimp was perfect, and the fish was outstanding and perfectly cooked.
We skipped dessert, but had a beer and a Mai Tai. The total bill, including a generous tip, was less than $30. Great service and food, very reasonable prices -- look for the giant shrimp on the roof.