Another place we found in the coupon book from the visitor's center (you should definitely pick up a book!). The large pizza is definitely LARGE (it fed me and my husband both dinner and the next day's lunch), and the garlic rolls are amazing. They are a bit pricey, but definitely worth it. The pizza is thin-crust (the way real Italian pizza is), and has a very liberal dose of toppings (they'll also give you half a pizza topping for half the price, which is great for us because my husband loves pepperoni & I can't stand the stuff - he got pepperoni & mushroom on his half, I had just mushrooms). The one bummer - no sweet tea. It's just not the same when the sugar's added once the tea is cold. But c'est la vie. Overall, a very excellent meal at a good price. They also have pasta dishes that seemed to be good-sized from what we saw on other's tables.
The place is located towards the back of a shopping complex, almost directly across from the OberGatlinburg ski lift stop (not the sky ride, the actual ski lift).