Somehow this place has been judged "best pizza on Maui" by The Maui News Reader’s Poll since 1998 and called "the best pizza I ever had" in Frommer’s guide to Maui. Apparently, these people do not like pizza. The pizza is very greasy, fairly bland, and the crust is very mushy. The pizza is average at best. If you want pizza, order from Pizza Hut just down the street.
We ordered a medium pepperoni pizza ($13.95), small Greek Salad ($4.25), spaghetti marinara with meatballs ($9.45) and their "famous" 12" garlic breadstick ($.85).
They forgot to give me my Greek salad when I picked up my order, so I can’t rate that. Garlic breadstick was left uneaten after 1 bite. The spaghetti was very delicious.
Restaurant interior is drab. The only other saving grace is that they also serve 16 flavors of ice cream.