Breaking the Rules and the Scales but not the Bank

• 4 out of 5 stars by Liam Hetherington from Manchester, United Kingdom
• January 11, 2011

Quote: On our first night in New York we broke one of my cardinal rules. We had a meal at a venue not just on a square but on Times Square. I have always been of the opinion that when you eat right next door to a famous landmark your bill will be... Read the full Carmine's Theater District review

From journal Eating the Big Apple, One Bite at a Time...

• Email
• Print
• Cheer!
• Flag

Great Italian Food

• 5 out of 5 stars by kennchris from Cicero, New York
• February 19, 2009

Quote: This is an excellent Italian restaurant in NYC. We went on a week night a few weeks before Christmas. We had a 5:30 reservation and it was a good thing because the place was packed and we never would have gotten a table without it. The restaurant... Read the full Carmine's Theater District review

• Email
• Print
• Cheer!
• Flag

Carmine's

• 5 out of 5 stars by pcterrilynn from Menifee, California
• November 29, 2006

Quote: Carmine's is a must when you visit New York. It is better with a group of at least 6. I am Italian and very rarely enjoy restaurant Italian food. Carmine's food was as good as my mom's. You order several entrées to share with the group. We all left... Read the full Carmine's Theater District review

From journal Vacationing

• Email
• Print
• Cheer!
• Flag

Carmine’s Restaurant: Outstanding Food

• 5 out of 5 stars by vi3tenvy from Jacksonville, Florida
• August 5, 2006

Quote: It was very nice. I liked it a lot, and there were very nice people there. I will go there again for sure. I want other people to go for a good experience.

From journal N.Y.

• Email
• Print
• Cheer!
• Flag

Carmine's

• 3 out of 5 stars by 2HogFans from Bella Vista, Arkansas
• February 1, 2006

Quote: On our first night in NYC, we decided to dine at Carmine's. By the time we got checked into our hotel, it was past lunchtime but not yet dinnertime. However, our group was starving, so we decided to eat a big meal. At 4pm on a Thursday, we got right... Read the full Carmine's Theater District review

From journal Long Winter Weekend in New York City

• Email
• Print
• Cheer!
• Flag

Carmine's

• 5 out of 5 stars by Samlawali from Lincolnton, North Carolina
• November 2, 2005

Quote: After the Toys 'R' Us sojourn and before we headed over to the Theater for our afternoon Broadway show, the group of us headed over to 44th Street to partake in some delicious Southern Italian cuisine. Carmine's is located right in the heart of the... Read the full Carmine's Theater District review

From journal Little Bite, Big Apple

• Email
• Print
• Cheer!
• Flag

Carmine's

• 3 out of 5 stars by lucinda3 from Alpharetta, Georgia
• April 22, 2005

Quote: Carmine's is best enjoyed with a large group of friends. The portions serve 2 to 4, depending on your appetite. The dining room is large and open, which creates a noisy, vibrant atmosphere. There is a range of classic Italian fare. The stuffed... Read the full Carmine's Theater District review

From journal NYC

• Email
• Print
• Cheer!
• Flag

Carmine's

• 5 out of 5 stars by themusicaltraveller from Laguna Hills, California
• March 17, 2005

Quote: If you have a large group in New York, then this is the place to go. This is perhaps one of the best Italian restaurants in New York. It is extremely popular, though, so make sure you make reservations before going. The restaurant is huge and... Read the full Carmine's Theater District review

From journal Two Days in The Big Apple

• Email
• Print
• Cheer!
• Flag

Carmine’s Restaurant: Outstanding Food

• 5 out of 5 stars by Backpackingrl from Buffalo, New York
• February 5, 2005

Quote: After a Broadway show, head to Carmine’s theater district restaurant for a very satisfying meal. Carmine’s offers a classy, yet relaxed, atmosphere for Italian food in the heart of Time’s Square. Being that Carmine’s is located a few blocks over... Read the full Carmine's Theater District review

From journal NYC: Times Square Eats

• Email
• Print
• Cheer!
• Flag

Carmine's

• 5 out of 5 stars by Alias Girl from New York, New York
• August 25, 2004

Quote: I'm sure there are hundreds of Carmine's recommendations on this website, so I'll keep mine short and hopefully not repetitive. This family-style restaurant caters to groups of three or more…anything less and it’s not worth going. You'll spend... Read the full Carmine's Theater District review

From journal New York City

• Email
• Print
• Cheer!
• Flag