St. Elmo Steak House

#1 most popular of 42 restaurants in Indianapolis

joebeaster writes, "I have eaten all over the U.S. There are some damn good steak houses in this…" »

Gambet writes, "St. Elmo's downtown gives a historic view of Indy. In the bar, pictures line the back…" »

Salute Italian Ristorante

#2 most popular of 42 restaurants in Indianapolis

HungryYum writes, "I would like to tell you about my favorite Italian restaurant. It could be described as a "hole in the wall", but it has authentic Italian food cooked by the authentic Italian owner and chef.…" »

Penn Station

#3 most popular of 42 restaurants in Indianapolis

Loaded Lux writes, "Yum, I’m sure that a majority of people who live on the East Coast have heard of Penn Station. This is my third-favorite place to eat. The subs are delicious. You can get a sub-wrapped pizza…" »

Red Eye Cafe

#4 most popular of 42 restaurants in Indianapolis

Nisi_Nirvani writes, "The Red Eye is a yummy all-night cafe conveniently located downtown. They have a wide variety of food, with everything from burgers to breakfast served all day. They serve all kinds of…" »

Thai Cafe

#5 most popular of 42 restaurants in Indianapolis

NLTNMNT writes, "Thai Café is a little, virtually unknown jewel in Indianapolis. Few people know about it, but it's some of the best Thai food you'll find in the Circle City. Thai Café is a bit tough to…" »

Shula's Steak House

#6 most popular of 42 restaurants in Indianapolis

edecker writes, "This place was awesome! It is a wonderful steak house. The steaks are huge! They're very, very tasty, and it's a great place to enjoy while in downtown Indy. Please enjoy the steaks while you…" »

Eagle's Nest

#7 most popular of 42 restaurants in Indianapolis

B238 writes, "I believe this is in the Hyatt downtown. It is a very elegant restaurant. It is on the 21st floor on top of the hotel and is a rotating restaurant. My advice would to get there about half an…" »

Bravo Kitchen Italiana

#8 most popular of 42 restaurants in Indianapolis

chelslor writes, "If you like Italian food, you need to eat here. The atmosphere is awesome and the staff was very friendly. The food was fabulous and they make the best desserts. We had this triple decker…" »

Ambrosia Restaurant

#9 most popular of 42 restaurants in Indianapolis

B238 writes, "This restaurant is a very nice establishment. It has a place to eat outside and a nice area inside, too. They have a nice fireplace, and the decor is nicely done. The food is great, as is the…" »

Shallo's Restaurant & Brewhouse

#10 most popular of 42 restaurants in Indianapolis

wanamaker00 writes, "I ordered a surf-and-turf, which was cooked to perfection. My waitress was very attentive and had a fun attitude. The entire restaurant has the air of a city pub, with all-American food,…" »