Add to Trip

Tap Room

#1 most popular of 36 restaurants in Nantucket

• "The restaurant that we enjoy the most in Nantucket is Jared’s at the Jared Coffin House. The upstairs…"
• "The Tap Room at the Jared Coffin House is a cosy pub carved out of the Coffin House's basement. In the…"

• Avg. Member Rating 4 of 5 Avg. Rating
• 3 reviews

Add to Trip

Old South Diner

#2 most popular of 36 restaurants in Nantucket

• "This place was close to our house rental, so we decided to stop here for breakfast on our way out to the beach for the day. We both ordered eggs with bacon, potatoes and toast. We had the choice of the potatoes…"

• Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
• 1 review

Add to Trip

Black Eyed Susan's

#5 most popular of 36 restaurants in Nantucket

• "This is a great place, my favourite eatery on the island, though there is no dial-in reservation system. Susan takes reservations on the porch of the restaurant at 6pm sharp for that evening's sittings, so get…"

• Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
• 1 review

Add to Trip

American Seasons

#6 most popular of 36 restaurants in Nantucket

• "Loved American Seasons restaurant. It was recommended to us by the innkeeper. We had the best experience here, very elegant and personal.. The ambiance and food was perfect for our anniversary dinner. This was…"

• Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
• 1 review

Add to Trip

Queequeg's Restaurant

#7 most popular of 36 restaurants in Nantucket

• "After searching through all the travel books we decided to try Queequeg's. We called and they were able to fit us in at at outside table, which at first I thought I might be chilly, but it was very pleasant. I…"

• Avg. Member Rating 4 of 5 Avg. Rating
• 1 review

Add to Trip

Brotherhood of Thieves

#10 most popular of 36 restaurants in Nantucket

• "I'd heard bad things about this place. It used to be an institution on the island but had burnt down and was replaced by a far more soulless recreation apparently. So yes, it has lost some of its quirky character…"

• Avg. Member Rating 3 of 5 Avg. Rating
• 1 review

Add to Trip

The Rose and Crown

#11 most popular of 36 restaurants in Nantucket

• "The Rose and Crown is in the heart of Nantucket Town on Water Street between Main St. and Broad St. It's a bar as well as a resturant (as a crowd of cheerful revelers around the bar attests), but there are also…"

• Avg. Member Rating 3 of 5 Avg. Rating
• 1 review

Add to Trip

Oran Mor

#12 most popular of 36 restaurants in Nantucket

• "I have never been so insulted and embarrassed at a restaurant. I booked a specific table well in advance…"
• "We called on a Sunday evening to make reservations at the restaurant during the Film Festival Weekend In…"

• Avg. Member Rating 3 of 5 Avg. Rating
• 2 reviews

Add to Trip

A.K. Diamonds

#13 most popular of 36 restaurants in Nantucket

• "I had to catch an evening flight out of nantucket, so we tried to find a place close to the airport for dinner and I found A. K. Diamonds, so we gave it a try. After spending over $150 dollars each of the two…"

• Avg. Member Rating 2 of 5 Avg. Rating
• 1 review

Add to Trip

Twenty One Federal

• Have you been here before? Be the first to write a review of Twenty One Federal