Sanibel Island Restaurants

Search Restaurants
Refine by Cuisine
Sort by: Most Popular | Most Reviewed
Results 11-20 of 22

Doc Ford's

#11 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island

  • "Our fishing guide had recommended Doc Fords and since it was a Rum Bar (my boyfriend's favorite drink) we…"
  • "If we'd had a week, we would have eaten our way through the menu. There was great seafood, soups - lots…"
  • Avg. Member Rating 4 of 5 Avg. Rating
  • 2 reviews

R.C. Otters

#12 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island

  • "This place is actually on Captiva island, which is adjacent to Sanibel by a small bridge on the north end of the island. The whole flavor of this place is different--it appears to be primarily expensive homes of…"
  • Avg. Member Rating 4 of 5 Avg. Rating
  • 1 review

Lazy Flamingo II

#13 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island

  • "This is a fun, lively local spot with good crab cakes, great buffalo shrimp, and FABULOUS SANGRIA. Though it is a bar-like place, it is definitely okay for kids, as it is very laid-back, not rowdy. The staff…"
  • Avg. Member Rating 4 of 5 Avg. Rating
  • 1 review

The Garden

#14 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island

  • "Owned by two Frenchmen, one of whom is the chef Jean Noel Bonnel, it featured French cuisine and fine local jazz. Many local musicians dropped in and jammed. The trumpet player sounded like the mellow style of…"
  • Avg. Member Rating 4 of 5 Avg. Rating
  • 1 review

Old Captiva House Restaurant at 'Tween-Water Inn

#15 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island

  • "Wonderful wait staff and service. I had a tasty half rack of lamb which was pan seared. Susan splurged on Surf and Turf with Julian veggies, special Scalloped Potatoes and a salad.…"
  • Avg. Member Rating 4 of 5 Avg. Rating
  • 1 review

Crabby Bill's

#16 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island

  • "Had lunch in Indian Rocks Beach along the Gulf. It is very well known. Susan had great crab cakes. I had very good grouper. We had a great view of the perpetual parade of auto traffic on Shore Drive. Enjoyed a…"
  • Avg. Member Rating 4 of 5 Avg. Rating
  • 1 review

Windows on the Water

#17 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island

  • "This very cozy restaurant, offers children's menu. Their Sunday bruch is famous in the area. When we visited we had to wait to get a table but we enjoyed the variety of different dishes they offered, from seafood…"
  • Avg. Member Rating 3 of 5 Avg. Rating
  • 1 review

The Sanibel Cafe

#18 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island

  • "Had a nice lunch there. The tables were glass tops above a "box" containing shells spray painted white. I think it was a project from Shell Craft 101.…"
  • Avg. Member Rating 3 of 5 Avg. Rating
  • 1 review

Pippin's Bar and Grill

#19 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island

  • "Tropical-themed restaurant. Children's menu, take out dinner, early bird specials. Steaks are aged and very well prepared. Also they serve chicken, fish and ribs. The place is intimate but family-oriented and…"
  • Avg. Member Rating 3 of 5 Avg. Rating
  • 1 review

Cafe Creole

#20 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island

  • "It has New Orleans style jazz on Friday and Saturday evenings. Susan enjoyed some great crab cakes. This was in 1994, so I am not sure if they are still in business.…"
  • Avg. Member Rating 3 of 5 Avg. Rating
  • 1 review
Sort by: Most Popular | Most Reviewed
Results 11-20 of 22

Compare Sanibel Island Rates

1. Enter travel information

City

2. Select websites to compare rates

Each selected website will open a new window.

Sanibel Island Travel Deals

All Sanibel Island Travel Deals