#2 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "Hands down the best "pizza" you will ever put in your face, with an addictive chemical that will make you…"
- "Before our trip to Boman's Beach on Sanibel Island, we had to stop and refuel the gas tanks for us and…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 2 reviews
#3 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "Mucky Duck in Sanibel Island, FL, serves to the variety of tourists in Sanibel, Captiva, and the various…"
- "The Mucky Duck seems to be a necessary stop for everyone staying in Sanibel or Captiva. From the moment…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 2 reviews
#4 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "We have travelled to many places in the world and although we love Sanibel we are continually let down by the quality of food in the restaurants. We are a family of 5 and regular visitors to Sanibel. We…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
#6 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "We had dinner at a very new and classy restaurant: the Moonlight, featuring Southwestern cuisine and decor. Joseph Archambault and James Taggart are the owners. The food was great. This was in 1994, so better…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
#15 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "Wonderful wait staff and service. I had a tasty half rack of lamb which was pan seared. Susan splurged on Surf and Turf with Julian veggies, special Scalloped Potatoes and a salad.…"
- Avg. Member Rating 4 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
#16 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "Had lunch in Indian Rocks Beach along the Gulf. It is very well known. Susan had great crab cakes. I had very good grouper. We had a great view of the perpetual parade of auto traffic on Shore Drive. Enjoyed a…"
- Avg. Member Rating 4 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
#18 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "Had a nice lunch there. The tables were glass tops above a "box" containing shells spray painted white. I think it was a project from Shell Craft 101.…"
- Avg. Member Rating 3 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
#19 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "Tropical-themed restaurant. Children's menu, take out dinner, early bird specials. Steaks are aged and very well prepared. Also they serve chicken, fish and ribs. The place is intimate but family-oriented and…"
- Avg. Member Rating 3 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
#20 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "It has New Orleans style jazz on Friday and Saturday evenings. Susan enjoyed some great crab cakes. This was in 1994, so I am not sure if they are still in business.…"
- Avg. Member Rating 3 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
Types of Sanibel Island American Restaurants
Sanibel Island
Tourism and Travel Guide