#1 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "Wonderful atmosphere. The food was wonderful, with the best New England chowder and fried shrimp on the…"
- "This was recommended by the resort staff, and they were right! The steak was so tender and grilled to…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 2 reviews
#2 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "Hands down the best "pizza" you will ever put in your face, with an addictive chemical that will make you…"
- "Before our trip to Boman's Beach on Sanibel Island, we had to stop and refuel the gas tanks for us and…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 2 reviews
#3 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "Mucky Duck in Sanibel Island, FL, serves to the variety of tourists in Sanibel, Captiva, and the various…"
- "The Mucky Duck seems to be a necessary stop for everyone staying in Sanibel or Captiva. From the moment…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 2 reviews
#4 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "We have travelled to many places in the world and although we love Sanibel we are continually let down by the quality of food in the restaurants. We are a family of 5 and regular visitors to Sanibel. We…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
#5 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "You'll probably have to wait for a table, but it's worth it. Amy's features wonderful breakfast items - omelettes, fresh-baked goods, etc., as well as juicy burgers and refreshing salads. The decor is cheerful…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
#6 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "We had dinner at a very new and classy restaurant: the Moonlight, featuring Southwestern cuisine and decor. Joseph Archambault and James Taggart are the owners. The food was great. This was in 1994, so better…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
#7 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "Located just before the bridge to Captiva. Brian and Jayne Baker, proprietors.
If this place is still in business, it is worth the cost! We have eaten there on other trips. (Our first visit was in 1994 was…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
#8 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "Enjoyed a wonderful Tapas meal operated by a wonderful friendly couple from Spain. Again the waiter was good. A little off, but really later when we spoke to him, turned out to be an interesting guy. Ted…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
#9 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "We had a great dinner here. Their specialty is Caribbean cuisine. To get there from I-275, take exit #13 (38th Ave. North) and proceed west to 28th Street. They're on the northwest corner. Park in the rear. …"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
#10 most popular of 22 restaurants in Sanibel Island
- "Approx. 70-80 miles from Tampa. Just south of Disney World a bit in central Florida.
The fantastic meal consisted of :
1. Cinnamon Grapefruit with chicken livers served in a cigar ashtray. Uh huh. I told…"
- Avg. Member Rating 5 of 5 Avg. Rating
- 1 review
Types of Sanibel Island Restaurants
Sanibel Island
Tourism and Travel Guide