Columbus Tavern

#1 most popular of 43 restaurants in Paradise Island

sopes writes, "It was nice to eat at a local restaurant while we were on Paradise Island. The seafood…" »

mainewolfie writes, "The Columbus Tavern waitstaff was worth the trip alone, but the food will keep you…" »

Murray's Delicatessen

#2 most popular of 43 restaurants in Paradise Island

Suzannecat writes, "I've listed Murray's as a budget restaurant, because by Atlantis standards it is. …" »

beachguy6 writes, "This place is like a diner. They serve good food and huge sandwiches. It's one of…" »

Marketplace

#3 most popular of 43 restaurants in Paradise Island

PaperTiger writes, "We ended up having to eat here everyday because we purchased a meal plan (which…" »

Suzannecat writes, "We splurged on the Marketplace breakfast buffet the first morning of our vacation…" »

Atlantis Dining

#4 most popular of 43 restaurants in Paradise Island

angel.w writes, "We ate our meals at Atlantis in one of about five different places. Three of the…" »

pasaw writes, "The best in the resort and worth every dime. The lobster and filet were the best I have…" »

The Point Poolside Restaurant & Bar

#5 most popular of 43 restaurants in Paradise Island

travelgrl92 writes, "The dinning at The Point was absolutely wonderful. It was located right off the…" »

smileygirl writes, "We had the opportunity to visit The Point Restaurant on our first day of arrival in…" »

Fathoms

#6 most popular of 43 restaurants in Paradise Island

capilitans writes, "Overlooking the main lagoon aquarium viewable from "The Dig" attraction at the Royal Towers. This restaurant is on the other side from the Café of the Great Halls of Water. It is not open…" »

Atlas Bar & Grill

#7 most popular of 43 restaurants in Paradise Island

travelgrl92 writes, "The Atlas Bar & Grill in Atlantis was a very nice place to eat. It is in the…" »

azsunluvr writes, "We ate here 3 times, mainly because it was the least expensive place to eat and was…" »

Anthony's Caribbean Grill

#8 most popular of 43 restaurants in Paradise Island

beachlovr0 writes, "We have visited Anthony's on several different trips to the Bahamas, and while the…" »

capilitans writes, "The place is much like a Bennigan's or TGIFriday's here in the U.S. but it does…" »

Blue Lagoon Restaurant

#9 most popular of 43 restaurants in Paradise Island

capilitans writes, "Best service in the island but the food did not measure up to the sophistication of…" »

Elk Rancher writes, "Our view was fantastic. They were very accommodating without hovering. We both…" »

Marketplace

#10 most popular of 43 restaurants in Paradise Island

rickhowe writes, "We spend part of the week after Christmas, and New Years, at the Atlantis Paradise Island. Prior to making our reservation, we decided NOT to purchase one of the Dining Plans, and we were…" »